Georgia Court of Appeals Upholds $8.5 Million Trucking Verdict and Clarifies How the New Trifurcation Law Works

In Transcontinental Carriers, Inc. v. Bennett, the court held that proof of a plaintiff’s injuries belongs in the fault phase of a trifurcated trial, and that a trucking company answers for the full judgment when its driver was acting on the job.
| The Case at a Glance | |
|---|---|
| Case | Transcontinental Carriers, Inc. et al. v. Bennett, No. A26A1643 |
| Court | Court of Appeals of Georgia, First Division |
| Decided | September 9, 2026 |
| Panel | Presiding Judge Barnes (author); Judges Markle and Hodges concurring |
| Verdict | $7,000,000 in damages plus $1,546,500 in attorney fees |
| Result | Judgment affirmed on every issue raised |
Key Takeaways
- Injury evidence comes in at phase one. Under OCGA § 51-12-15, evidence of what injuries the plaintiff suffered and how they developed after the crash may be heard in the fault-only first phase, because fault in Georgia means a breach of duty that proximately caused the injury.
- No mistrial over a straying expert. A judge who polices an expert witness and gives a curative instruction does not have to declare a mistrial when the expert drifts into whether a federal regulation was violated.
- Bad-faith fees can follow dangerous conduct. A driver’s conscious disregard of a known, dangerous medical condition can support an attorney-fee award under OCGA § 13-6-11, and a witness may testify that a specific contingency percentage is reasonable and customary.
- The employer pays the driver’s share. When an employer is liable under respondeat superior, the jury’s 30/70 split between driver and company does not reduce the company’s liability for the judgment.
ATLANTA — A Georgia jury’s $8.5 million verdict for a truck driver who suffered a permanent spinal cord injury after another tractor-trailer forced him into a guardrail on Interstate 75 will stand. On September 9, 2026, the Court of Appeals of Georgia affirmed the judgment in Transcontinental Carriers, Inc. v. Bennett, rejecting every argument raised by the trucking company, its insurer, and the administrator of its late driver’s estate.
The opinion reaches well past one crash. The case was tried in June 2025, about two months after OCGA § 51-12-15 took effect as part of Georgia’s 2025 tort reform legislation, and it was split into three phases under that new statute. The appeal gave the Court of Appeals a chance to explain how the trifurcation statute works in practice. The opinion also addresses expert testimony about federal trucking rules, attorney-fee claims based on bad faith, and how fault is allocated between a trucking company and its driver.
What Happened on I-75
On July 1, 2020, Lewis Bennett was driving a tractor-trailer northbound on I-75 in Houston County when a Transcontinental Carriers truck driven by company employee James Evans overtook him and failed to maintain its lane, moving from a left lane into Bennett’s right-hand lane. Bennett was forced across the emergency lane and into the guardrail. The 43,000-pound load in his trailer shifted on impact, and his head whipped in several directions; the opinion records testimony comparing the motion to a bobblehead.
Evans never stopped. He kept driving for several miles, with Bennett following behind, until several police vehicles forced him off an exit ramp and boxed him in. Police later learned that multiple 911 callers had reported the truck weaving and running other vehicles off the road before the collision.
The investigating officer observed signs of intoxication and found a diabetes treatment kit in the cab. Evans admitted the insulin supplies were his and that he had not taken insulin that day, though he denied being diabetic. When the officer had him test his own blood sugar, the reading was very high, indicating a medical emergency, and the hospital later confirmed he had gone at least two days without insulin. His medical records showed Type 1 diabetes diagnosed in 1995, a requirement to take insulin four times a day, a long history of neglecting treatment (even after a 2016 gangrenous infection that required surgery), and a pattern of misleading his doctors and employers about his condition. Evans died in August 2021.
Transcontinental said it required its drivers to comply with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, which allow drivers with diabetes to operate commercial vehicles only when the condition is properly controlled. But the evidence showed the company never looked further than a driver’s medical examiner’s certificate, did not notice the testing equipment in Evans’s truck, and did not take him out of service after the crash.
Bennett did not report any injuries at the scene. He began feeling nauseated soon afterward, his symptoms worsened, and within a few days he was admitted to an emergency room for spinal cord surgery. He went on to need further treatment and surgery for a permanent spinal cord injury and bladder dysfunction, and he developed gait problems that require him to use a four-point walker.
The Trial and the Verdict
Bennett sued in October 2020, naming Transcontinental, its insurer Occidental Fire & Casualty Company, and Evans. In discovery, Transcontinental admitted it was responsible for Evans’s actions under respondeat superior, the rule that makes an employer liable for an employee’s negligence on the job. The company later tried to withdraw that admission; the trial court refused, and the company did not challenge that ruling on appeal.
The June 2025 trial proceeded in three phases: causation and fault first, compensatory damages second, and Bennett’s claim for attorney fees under OCGA § 13-6-11 third. The jury assigned 30 percent of the fault to Evans and 70 percent to Transcontinental, awarded $7 million in damages, and awarded $1,546,500 in attorney fees. The trial court entered judgment on the verdict, and the defendants appealed. The Georgia Trial Lawyers Association filed an amicus brief, which the court acknowledged in its opinion.
What the Court of Appeals Decided
Evidence of injuries belongs in the fault phase
The defense’s lead argument was that Bennett should not have been allowed to describe the development, effects, and persistence of his injuries during phase one. The new statute says the evidence and arguments in the first phase “shall be limited” to fault and apportionment, and the defendants argued that admitting injury evidence erased the line between the fault phase and the damages phase.
The court disagreed. The statute asks the jury in phase one to decide whether a defendant is at fault “for the plaintiff’s injuries,” and Georgia law has long defined fault as a breach of duty that proximately caused the injury the plaintiff is suing over. A jury cannot decide whether a crash caused an injury without hearing about the injury. The defendants themselves conceded that the jury had to decide in phase one whether Bennett suffered a central cord syndrome injury as a result of the crash, and their trial theme was that the guardrail impact was too minor to have caused it. That argument, the court said, was a fault question for the jury.
The court also explained why the statute still does its job. The trial judge held evidence of Bennett’s permanent injuries, and any evidence of the extent of compensatory damages, for phase two, so the jury decided fault without knowing how much compensation he was seeking. Admitting the injury evidence in phase one was within the trial court’s discretion.
No mistrial over the trucking-safety expert
Before trial, the court barred experts from stating conclusions of law. At trial, Bennett’s expert testified that Evans had not complied with regulatory standards and, later, that Evans was not qualified to drive under the federal regulations. The judge responded to the defense objections by telling the expert that the court decides what the regulations mean, limiting him to the standard of care, and instructing the jury that it did not have to accept expert testimony and that it alone would decide whether any regulation was violated. When the expert drifted again, the judge redirected him. Only then did the defense move for a mistrial.
The Court of Appeals found no abuse of discretion. The judge had been vigilant, responded promptly, and gave a proper curative instruction; plaintiff’s counsel had not solicited the improper answers; and the testimony was cumulative of other evidence from which the jury could infer that Evans’s uncontrolled diabetes left him unqualified to drive.
Bad-faith attorney fees, and how to prove them
OCGA § 13-6-11 allows a jury to award attorney fees and litigation expenses when the defendant acted in bad faith in the transaction underlying the lawsuit. The court relied on Supreme Court of Georgia precedent holding that evidence sufficient to support punitive damages also supports a bad-faith finding, along with a line of Georgia cases treating impaired or dangerous driving as conscious indifference to the consequences. Applying those cases, it held that Evans’s history of consciously disregarding the danger of driving without medication he knew he needed was enough to support the jury’s bad-faith finding.
The defense also objected to testimony about customary contingency-fee percentages in injury cases. The court noted that Bennett’s own fee agreement was never introduced, and that OCGA § 9-15-16(b) bars only the introduction of a fee agreement as proof that the fees are reasonable. Citing the Supreme Court of Georgia’s 2026 decision in Cayamcela v. Advocacy Trust, the court held that testimony that a specific percentage fee was reasonable and customary for the work involved was a proper way to prove the fees.
The trucking company pays for its driver’s share, too
The defendants asked the court to limit Transcontinental’s liability to the 70 percent of fault the jury assigned to it. The court declined. Under respondeat superior, the employer is entirely responsible for its employee’s negligence, and fault cannot be apportioned between the employer and the employee who caused the harm. The defendants also argued that the judgment should not have run against the insurer in an amount above its policy limits, but the court did not reach that question because the defendants first raised it in the trial court after filing their notice of appeal.
Why This Decision Matters
Georgia’s 2025 tort reform law changed how injury cases are tried, and the trifurcation statute is one of its most significant procedural changes. Defendants have every incentive to read phase one as narrowly as possible, so that the jury learns little about what happened to the injured person until fault has already been decided. Bennett rejects that reading. A jury deciding fault may hear about the injuries the defendant is accused of causing, because causation is part of fault.
The case is also a reminder of what trucking cases often turn on. The jury placed 70 percent of the fault on the motor carrier rather than the driver. The record described a company that accepted a medical certificate at face value, missed diabetic testing equipment in the cab, and kept the driver in service after the crash. Driver qualification, medical oversight, and what a carrier did after warning signs appeared are exactly the kinds of evidence a thorough investigation develops early.
At Haug Barron Law Group, we try catastrophic trucking, injury, and wrongful death cases in Georgia’s State Courts under the rules as they now stand, including the new trifurcation procedure. We also accept litigation referrals from pre-suit firms when a case cannot be resolved without filing suit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a trifurcated trial in Georgia?
A trifurcated trial is split into three phases in front of the same judge and jury. Under OCGA § 51-12-15, the jury first decides whether any defendant is at fault and assigns percentages of fault. If it finds fault, the trial moves straight into a second phase on compensatory damages. If damages are awarded, a third phase can follow on issues such as punitive damages, attorney fees, and expenses of litigation.
Who can demand a trifurcated trial, and when?
In any case seeking damages for bodily injury or wrongful death, any party may demand trifurcation in writing before the pretrial order is entered. A timely demand is binding: the trial court must trifurcate. That is different from the general rule in OCGA § 9-11-42(b), which leaves separate trials to the judge’s discretion.
When did the trifurcation law take effect?
OCGA § 51-12-15 took effect on April 21, 2025, as part of Georgia’s 2025 tort reform legislation. Bennett itself was filed in October 2020 and tried in three phases under the new statute in June 2025.
Can I tell the jury about my injuries in the first phase?
Under Bennett, evidence of the injuries you suffered and how they developed after the crash may come in during phase one, because proving fault in Georgia means proving that the defendant’s breach of duty caused your injuries. What waits for phase two is evidence of the extent of your compensatory damages. Trial judges still have discretion over where specific evidence belongs; Bennett held that this judge did not abuse that discretion.
What if the defense says the crash was too minor to cause my injuries?
That is a question for the jury. In Bennett, the defense argued that the guardrail impact was too minor to cause a spinal cord injury. The Court of Appeals said that argument goes to fault in phase one and is for the jury, not the judge, to resolve.
I felt fine at the scene. Can I still have a claim?
Possibly. Bennett did not report any injuries at the scene. He felt nauseated soon afterward, and within a few days he was in surgery for a spinal cord injury that turned out to be permanent. Delayed symptoms are not unusual after a crash, and they did not stop Bennett from recovering. Anyone with new or worsening symptoms after a collision should see a doctor promptly.
Can a trucking company be held responsible when its driver has a medical condition?
A trucking company is liable for its driver’s negligence on the job under respondeat superior, and it can also be found at fault for its own conduct. In Bennett, the jury assigned 70 percent of the fault to the carrier after hearing evidence that it looked no further than a medical examiner’s certificate, missed the diabetic testing equipment in the truck, and kept the driver in service after the crash. Federal motor carrier rules allow drivers with diabetes to operate commercial vehicles only when the condition is properly controlled.
If the jury splits fault between the driver and the company, does the company pay only its share?
Not when the company is liable for the driver under respondeat superior. The court held that an employer is entirely responsible for its employee’s negligence and that fault cannot be apportioned between them, so Transcontinental remained liable for the judgment and not just for its 70 percent.
Can an expert testify that a trucker violated federal safety regulations?
Bennett shows where one trial court drew the line. Experts could explain the regulations and how they relate to the standard of care, but they could not state conclusions of law, apply the regulations to the driver’s conduct, or say that a regulation was violated. The court decides what the regulations mean, and the jury decides whether they were violated. When the plaintiff’s expert crossed that line, prompt objections, corrections from the bench, and a curative instruction were enough; no mistrial was required.
Can I recover attorney fees in a Georgia injury case?
Sometimes. OCGA § 13-6-11 allows a jury to award attorney fees and litigation expenses when the defendant acted in bad faith in the underlying transaction, was stubbornly litigious, or caused the plaintiff unnecessary trouble and expense. In Bennett, the driver’s conscious disregard of a known, dangerous medical condition supported a bad-faith award of $1,546,500.
Can the jury hear about a contingency fee?
Under OCGA § 9-15-16(b), the fee agreement itself cannot be introduced as proof that the fees are reasonable. But Bennett, following the Supreme Court of Georgia’s 2026 decision in Cayamcela v. Advocacy Trust, confirms that a witness may testify that a specific percentage fee is reasonable and customary for the work involved.
Is the Bennett decision final?
The Court of Appeals issued its opinion on September 9, 2026. A party may move for reconsideration, which must be received by the clerk within ten days of the decision, or ask the Supreme Court of Georgia to review the case. This article describes the opinion as issued.
What should I do if I was hurt in a truck crash in Georgia?
Get medical care, keep records of your treatment and symptoms, and talk with a trial lawyer before giving a statement to the trucking company’s insurer. Important evidence, such as electronic logging data, driver qualification files, and dispatch records, can be lost if no one acts to preserve it. Georgia’s deadline for most personal injury claims is two years from the date of injury, with some exceptions.
If you or a loved one was seriously injured in a commercial truck crash in Georgia, a plaintiff-only trial firm that investigates the carrier’s driver qualification and medical oversight, preserves critical evidence early, and tries cases under Georgia’s new trifurcation rules can hold every responsible party fully accountable. Contact Haug Barron Law Group today for a free, confidential consultation to protect your right to full compensation.
This article summarizes a published appellate opinion for general information. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. © Haug Barron Law Group, Personal Injury Lawyers. All rights reserved.
Contact Haug Barron Law Group Today for a FREE Consultation.